Thursday, December 10, 2015

Historic Dunn's Bridge on the Kankakee River

Dunn's Bridge, located on County Road 500 East, south of Kouts, Indiana, in Pleasant Township, spans the Kankakee River. The precise year in which the original bridge span was constructed seems lost to history, but numerous published sources indicate that the bridge was erected at some point in time between 1895 and 1904.

Construction of Dunn's Bridge over the Kankakee River, year unknown.
Source: Meyer's The Story of Kankakee Township, 1979. [see p.23]

The 1895-1904 time frame that Dunn's Bridge was presumably originally constructed may not be correct. Why? Dunn's Bridge is mentioned in at least three publications prior to 1895. For instance, John Collett, State Geologist, specifically mentions Dunn's Bridge in the 1882 annual report for the Indiana Department of Geology and Natural History, which was published in 1883. John Lyle Campbell mentions Dunn's Bridge in his Report Upon the Improvement of the Kankakee River and Drainage of the Marsh Lands of Indiana, also published in 1883.

First known published mention of Dunn's Bridge.
Source: Campbell's Report Upon the Improvement of the Kankakee River, 1883. [see p. 11]

Interestingly, John Lyle Campbell had promoted the construction of a shipping canal connecting Lake Michigan with the Gulf of Mexico. As reported in the April 17, 1893, issue of The Indianapolis Journal, Campbell's proposed route would follow the boundary between the counties of Lake and Porter at Lake Michigan and then turned slightly southward toward Baum's Bridge on the Kankakee River. The canal would then follow the Kankakee River to Dunn's Bridge, where it would turn south toward the Monon River near Medaryville. From the Monon River, the route would travel to the Tippecanoe River, thence to the Wabash, Ohio, and Mississippi. Despite the canal never being seriously considered by the State of Indiana, Campbell clearly had a vision, stating:
"The Kankakee is our sleeping giant, which needs only be aroused that its mighty power may be used for the benefit of the State and Nation."
Perhaps the arched Dunn's Bridge we know today was not the original bridge spanning the Kankakee River at County Road 500 East? 

An additional factor leading to some confusion related to the date of the construction of Dunn's Bridge is that Porter County issued a notice for bids for "removal and replacing" the bridge in 1915. The removal was not an actual demolition of the bridge and the erection of a new bridge. Rather, the commissioners of Porter County and Jasper County agreed to pay for the temporary removal of the middle sixty feet of the bridge. The removal was to allow the passage of the McWilliams dredge, which was instrumental in the creation of Marble Ditch. The central portion of the bridge was removed, swung to the bank of the river, and then replaced after the passage of the dredge.

Example of a notice for bids for the removal and placement of Dunn's Bridge in 1915.
Source: Engineering and Contracting, March 31, 1915. [see p. 31]

The bridge is named after farmer Isaac Dunn, a native of Maine. Dunn resided in Jasper County and had farm land on both sides of the river. It has been noted that Dunn erected the bridge as a means of moving his farming equipment from one side of the Kankakee River to the other side. One biography of Isaac Dunn states that he built two bridges. The first bridge was a wooden structure that spanned the Kankakee; this bridge was later replaced by Dunn with a "fine iron bridge." Unfortunately, Dunn's biography does not indicate the year that either bridge was constructed.

Postcard image of Dunn's Bridge published by the
Albert Hahn Company and postmarked in 1909.
Source: Collection of Steven R. Shook.

It has long been rumored that the structural frame of Dunn's Bridge was constructed from iron trusses taken from the world's first Ferris wheel that operated at the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago, Illinois. This rumor is strongly believed to be untrue. First, the top of the bridge arch flattens out, while all of the components of the Ferris wheel were composed of continuous curves. More importantly, the 1893 Ferris wheel from the World's Columbian Exposition was removed to St. Louis, Missouri, for use at the 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition. At the conclusion of the exposition at St. Louis, the Ferris wheel was dynamited on May 11, 1906, and sold for scrap. Thus, the bridge's construction predated the dismantling of the Ferris wheel. And it is very unlikely that scrap metal obtained from a structure that was dismantled using dynamite would be used for the construction of a bridge where life safety is of paramount concern.

Postcard image of Dunn's Bridge taken from
Burrow's Camp,
postmarked in 1913.
Source: Collection of Steven R. Shook.

The arch of the bridge is fabricated from two six-panel, three three-panel, and two six-panel sections that are bolted to one another. I-beams sitting upon concrete abutments support the deck of the bridge at the approaches. Open girder and I-beams support the bridge deck. Each arch is attached to the deck beams by five eyebars.

It is probable that the bridge trusses did indeed originate from the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition, but more likely from one of the domed or barrel-arched structures that were dismantled after the exposition. One persistent theory is that the arches were obtained from the dismantled Administration Building from the World's Columbian Exposition.

 Postcard image of auto race crossing Dunn's Bridge postmarked in 1915.
Source: Collection of Steven R. Shook.

This theory is supported by Kay Folsom Nichols, who writes about Dunn's Bridge in her book The Kankakee, published in 1965. She writes (pp. 173-174):
"Another was the building of Dunn's bridge. It was the first iron bridge built on the upper end of the River, and was fashioned from iron salvaged from the dome of the Administration building of the World's Columbian Exposition - THE Chicago World's Fair of 1893.

P. E. Lane, a Boston engineer, conceived the idea of salvaging iron from the domes and roofs of the great building which were of fabricated iron. He visioned this material going into bridges at low cost, and so it happened that during the next few years after the fair closed, the streams and rivers of Northern Indiana, particularly Lake and Porter counties, and that part of Illinois nearest Chicago, were furnished with bridge material whose first purpose had been to shelter exhibits from all over the world. There are many of these structures still in use today."
Wesley Meyer, in his book The Story of Kankakee Township (Jasper County), sheds some additional light about Dunn's Bridge.  Meyer's writes (p. 22) that:
"He [a reporter from the Chicago Tribune] was told that Dunn went to Chicago in 1894 and bought parts of the giant ferris wheel which was used in Chicago's Columbian Exposition of 1893. The worn out parts were scheduled for replacement. The scrap was transported to Dunn's property by rail and horse-drawn carts, and then constructed over the river by Jasper and Porter Counties."
No evidence has been found to support the contention that the Ferris wheel had major structural elements replaced prior to its removal from Chicago to St. Louis. Furthermore, given that the arches were structural components rather than mechanical components of the Ferris wheel, there should have been no need to replace them due to the fact that they were "worn out."

Meyer also states that records in the Jasper County Highway Department include notes from a bridge survey conducted by E. D. Nesbitt, county surveyor, on January 6, 1933. Nesbitt wrote that Dunn's bridge was constructed using "curved roof trusses from a World's Fair building used in Chicago in 1893."

 Administration Building, World's Columbian Exposition in
Chicago, 1893. The arches used to construct the dome
of this building may have been used to construct Dunn's Bridge.
Source: Official Views of the World's Columbian Exposition, 1893, Plate 23.

Nesbitt also wrote in his report that the south one-half of the Dunn's Bridge had been painted (Jasper County's section), while the "north half was not painted" (Porter County's section).

Yet another source for the arches can be traced back to a joint meeting between the Commissioners of Porter County and Jasper County on June 11, 1895. The meeting was held since the bridge spanning the river at that time was considered "unsafe." This meeting was held in the law offices of Judge Crumpacker, at Hammond. Meyer writes of this meeting, stating that (p. 22):
"The proposed bridge's specifications are spelled out in detail in the commissioner's records and are definitely those of Dunn's bridge.

At a meeting a week later, the two boards opened almost a dozen bids, some for wood and others for an iron and steel structure. The boards decided on an iron-steel structure. The same day a contract was signed with Lane Bridge and Iron Works of Chicago. According to the 'high cost' (high for then) it was assumed the firm supplied its own metal."
Meyer includes one additional twist in his account of Dunn's Bridge. He indicates that the commissioner records of Jasper County are silent as to Dunn's Bridge from 1894 to 1900. The commissioner records do reveal, however, that Isaac Dunn was provided funds in the amount of $196 and $895 for bridge construction.

News item concerning iron bridge construction at "Dunville."
Source: Chesterton Tribune, December 20, 1895.
More definitive information about Dunn's Bridge can be obtained by closely reviewing local newspapers. A news item appearing in the December 20, 1895, issue of the Chesterton Tribune indicates that work on an iron bridge was taking place "near Dunville." Another long article concerning bridge building in Porter County was published in The Westchester Tribune on October 23, 1897, and this article puts a rather reliable date on the building of the iron-constructed Dunn's Bridge and clearly identifies its builder.

In this long article, an individual signing themselves as "A Taxpayer" had become annoyed with the fact that P. E. Lane of the Lane Bridge & Iron Works, who was from Illinois, was receiving numerous contracts to construct bridge spans throughout Porter County. "A Taxpayer" complained that the county commissioners were allowing "old iron of the World's Fair, corroded, rusty, and full of holes" to be "dumped on the people of Porter county." In this article, it is also mentioned that the auditor of Porter County had paid the Lane Bridge & Iron Works on November 13, 1895, for the construction of "Dunn's bridge." Thus, Dunn's Bridge was constructed in November and December 1895 by the Lane Bridge & Iron Works using iron originating from buildings that were razed after the conclusion of the 1893 World's Fair in Chicago.

Between 1895 and 1897, the Lane Bridge & Iron Works had constructed at least six other bridges using discarded World’s Fair iron in Porter County.

Three of these bridges were located in Westchester Township, one being the bridge over Coffee Creek in Chesterton where today’s Porter Avenue now spans this creek, another spanning Coffee Creek on today's Brummitt Road (just west of the Brummitt School), and the third being located just west of the present day Howe Road bridge over the Little Calumet River.

One thirty-six foot long trestle bridge was constructed in Morgan Township over Crooked Creek on present day Indiana State Road 49, just north of County Road 500 South. Another bridge was built in Washington Township just west of present day County Road 400 East along Indiana State Road 2. Finally, in Jackson Township, the Lane Bridge & Iron Company constructed a bridge where present day Mander Road spans Coffee Creek, which was replaced in the 1970s.

Dunn’s Bridge is the only known surviving bridge that the Lane Bridge & Iron Works built in Porter County. In 1895, Porter County paid Lane Bridge & Iron Works $3,613.45 for the materials to construct Dunn's Bridge. It is unclear from the source of this information as to whether this represented one-half of the materials costs, with Jasper County paying the other one-half, or if this amount was the total cost of materials.

Given the totality of the facts, it appears that P. E. Lane's Chicago firm, Lane Bridge & Iron Works Company, supplied the materials for the erection of Dunn's Bridge. To date, however, no evidence has been uncovered to determine exactly who designed the bridge, what company erected it, or the origin of the metal arches assuming they were indeed reclaimed materials.

Bridge constructed in 1896 by the Lane Bridge & Iron Works over
Coffee Creek in Chesterton using discarded 1893 World's Fair iron.
Today, this road is known as Porter Avenue.
Source: Collection of Steven R. Shook.

Cover page from Lane Bridge & Iron Works' 1889 illustrated catalog.

Dunn's Bridge was purchased by the Porter County Parks and Recreation Board for $8,800 in 1999 and today it is Dunn's Bridge County Park. The bridge was restored in the early 2000s, which resulted in an award at the Fifteenth Annual Engineering Banquet sponsored by the American Council of Engineering Companies of Indiana in 2003. Butler-Fairman and Seufert, Inc., of Indianapolis, now Butler, Fairman & Seufert, were the recipients of the award for their work on the project.

Note that the Sugar Creek Chapel Bridge, which spans Sugar Creek and is located approximately three miles east of Milford, Iroquois County, Illinois, is extremely similar in design and construction to the Dunn's Bridge design. P. E. Lane designed the Sugar Creek Chapel Bridge, which was erected in 1904. Hence, there may be a relationship in the construction and building of the Sugar Creek Chapel Bridge and Dunn's Bridge.

 Postcard image of a gathering at Chaplain's Park
adjacent to
Dunn's Bridge,
postmarked in 1911.
Source: Collection of Steven R. Shook.

Source Material
Arnott, Beulah. 1984. Sketches of Jasper County. Rennselaer, Indiana: Jasper County Historical Society. 18 p. [see p. 4]

Blatchley, W. S. 1898. "The Geology of Lake and Porter Counties, Indiana," (pp. 25-104) In: Indiana Department of Geology and Natural Resources, 22nd Annual Report. Indianapolis, Indiana: William B. Buford. 1,197 p. [see pp. 56 and 104]

Campbell, John Lyle. 1883. Report Upon the Improvement of the Kankakee River and the Drainage of the Marsh Lands of Indiana. Indianapolis, Indiana: William B. Buford. 34 p. [see p. 11]

Carlton, Donna. 1995. Looking for Little Egypt. Bloomington, Indiana: International Dance Discovery. 103 p. [see p. 91]

Collett, John. 1883. Indiana Department of Geology and Natural History, Twelfth Annual Report. Indianapolis, Indiana: William B. Buford. 400 p. [see p. 78]

Hamilton, Louis H., and William Darroch. 1916. A Standard History of Jasper and Newton Counties, Indiana. Volume II. Chicago, Illinois: The Lewis Publishing Company. 357 p. [see pp. 670-671]

Lane Bridge & Iron Works. 1889. Illustrated Catalog: Lane Bridge & Iron Works. Chicago, Illinois: Rand, McNally & Company. 12 p.

Nichols, Kay Folsom. 1965. The Kankakee: Chronicle of an Indiana River and Its Fabled Marshes. Brooklyn, New York: Theodore Gaus' Sons, Inc. 209 p. [see pp. 173-174]

Meyer, Wesley. 1979. The Story of Kankakee Township. Rensselaer, Indiana: Kurtz Printing Company. 64 p. [see. 22-24]

Wolfsie, Dick. 2009. Indiana Curiosities: Quirky Characters, Roadside Oddities, and Other Offbeat Stuff. Third Edition. Guilford, Connecticut: Globe Pequot Press. 336 p. [see pp. 315-316]

Engineering and Contracting, Chicago, Cook County, Illinois; March 31, 1915; Volume 43, Number 15, Page 31, Column 3. Column titled "Bridges, Bids Asked."

Good Roads, New York, New York County, New York; April 10, 1915; Volume 9, Number 15; Page 9, Column 2. 
Newspapers (listed by date of publication)
The Indianapolis Journal, Indianapolis, Marion County, Indiana; April 17, 1893; Page 6, Column 5. Column titled "The Proposed Ship Canal" by J. L. Campbell.

Chesterton Tribune, Chesterton, Porter County, Indiana; May 24, 1895; Volume 12, Number 7, Page 1, Column 5. Column titled "Porter Pointers. On the Movements and Doings of Its People."

Chesterton Tribune, Chesterton, Porter County, Indiana; December 20, 1895; Volume 12, Number 36, Page 1, Column 4. Column titled "About the County. Kouts."

The Westchester Tribune, Chesterton, Porter County, Indiana; October 23, 1897; Volume 14, Number 28, Page 1, Columns 3-5. Column titled "Those Iron Bridges. A Correspondent Asks Pertinent Questions About Them. And is Answered With the Testimony Given by Chairman Fulton of the County Board of Commissioners, Who Makes Some Startling Admissions."

The Chesterton Tribune, Chesterton, Porter County, Indiana; December 25, 1897. Volume 14, Number 37, Page 1, Columns 1-2. Column titled "The News of the Week. Taxpayer of Valparaiso Throws a Bombshell Into Camp by Claiming the County Commissioners Have a New Bird to Throw Money at."

The Vidette-Messenger, Valparaiso, Porter County, Indiana; March 15, 1930; Volume 3, Page 7, Column 3. Column titled "Do You Remember the Day?"

The Vidette-Messenger, Valparaiso, Porter County, Indiana; March 30, 1976; Volume 49, Number 226, Page 9, Columns 1-4. Column titled "Popular Dunn's Bridge Legend Doesn't Stand Up to Weight of Facts Uncovered by Reporter" by Jo Mannies.

The Vidette-Messenger, Valparaiso, Porter County, Indiana; March 6, 1976; Volume 49, Number 206, Page 1, Column 1. Column titled "Over a Cup of Coffee."

The Times, Munster, Lake County, Indiana; July 23, 1998. Column titled "Dunn's Bridge Close to Restoration" by Steve Walsh.

The Times, Munster, Lake County, Indiana; December 3, 1999. Column titled "County Acquires Dunn's Bridge" by Rae Ann Rockhill.

Chesterton Tribune, Chesterton, Porter County, Indiana; April 4, 2003. Column titled "Dunn's Bridge Restoration Wins State Engineering Award" by Vicki Urbanik.

The Times, Munster, Lake County, Indiana; October 11, 2005. Column titled "Dunn's Bridge, A Historical Mystery, to be Rededicated Friday."

Chesterton Tribune, Chesterton, Porter County, Indiana; October 17, 2005. Column titled "Dunn's Bridge Officially Opened as Porter County Park," by Vicki Urbanik.

© 2015 Steven R. Shook. All Rights Reserved.

1 comment:

  1. What a great place to have been and experienced in 1870 to 1890 headed west across this great nation! Bob McKissack Texan